Cambridge University Press published a study based on a survey of 24 European universities, it was led by Manuel Heitor, Portugal’s former Minister of Science, Technology and Higher Education, with co-authors based in Switzerland, Belgium, Norway and the Netherlands. At one university, 77% of researchers were on temporary contracts. At another, the figure was just 10.6%. Permanent contracts were the norm at most universities that reported these figures, which makes the gap all the more striking. A researcher’s prospects can differ dramatically from one European university to the next. Europe is asking the world’s brightest researchers to “Choose Europe”. What, exactly, are they being asked to choose?
In August, I argued that a genuinely science-based civilization would put intellectual discovery at the centre of its ambitions. I also asked how much intelligence we waste when the institutions entrusted with cultivating it make caution the safest career strategy. Consider the choice facing a researcher whose next salary depends on the next grant. They can spend years on a difficult, unfashionable question whose answer may overturn a prevailing assumption, or they can pursue a line of work likely to yield something publishable before the next application deadline. Science advances by failure but rewards only certainty, and “Choose Europe” rings hollow when those who accept the invitation must choose between the question worth asking and the one most likely to keep them employed for a little longer.
In July, in the post The Battle for the World’s Brightest Minds I wrote about China’s efforts to recruit leading scientists by giving them the resources and time to pursue ambitious work. One of the offers I discussed was a twenty-year research endowment. Imagine the questions a scientist could finally afford to ask with that much time. Now imagine asking a researcher to commit to a question that may take a decade to answer when their university can only tell them who will pay their salary for the next two years. The next time Europe asks the world’s brightest minds to “Choose Europe”, it should be prepared to answer a question any of them would be entitled to ask. How far ahead can I afford to think if I accept your offer?


